Pennsylvania Wireless Association

The Voice of the Wireless Industry in Pennsylvania...

Industry News

NAB Signs on to Proposal Regarding Towers and Birds

On May 3, 2010, after extensive negotiations, NAB and six other organizations submitted to the FCC a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) that contained recommendations designed to help the FCC protect migratory birds as part of its Antenna Structure Registration (ASR) process.

Two years ago, the federal appeals court in Washington, D.C. ordered the FCC to expeditiously change its ASR program and to give public notice prior to granting tower applications. At the request of the FCC, NAB, along with other industry Infrastructure Coalition Members (CTIA - The Wireless Association, PCIA and the National Association of Tower Erectors) and the conservation groups (comprised of the American Bird Conservancy, the Defenders of Wildlife and the National Audubon Society) entered negotiations to develop interim standards that would be used for the ASR program.

The conservation groups were pressing the FCC to adopt an aggressive set of policies and procedures, including Environment Assessments (EA) for all towers, which would have slowed ASR grants from overnight to over a year. In addition, many of their suggestions would have seriously impeded the approval of taller towers.

The agreement covers towers for which an ASR is required to be filed. Depending upon the height of the proposed tower or the specifications of a replacement tower, some would require an EA to be performed to access the tower's impact on migratory birds and would be placed on public notice (per court order), others (e.g., shorter towers, replacement towers, repaired towers) could be exempted from the process. Among other things, the MOU proposes three ASR categories:

Category #1 - New Towers taller than 450 feet above ground level (AGL).

  • ASRs always require inclusion of an EA upon filing.
  • ASRs will always be placed on Public Notice by the FCC.

    Category #2 - New Towers of a height of 351 to 450 feet AGL.

  • ASRs do not initially require an EA based on avian concerns.
  • ASRs will always be placed on Public Notice by the FCC.
  • The FCC will determine whether an EA is necessary for Category #2 ASRs after reviewing the ASR application and any filings made in response to the Public Notice.

    Category #3 - New Towers of a height no greater than 350 feet AGL, Replacement Towers and Minor ASRs.

  • ASRs do not require an EA upon filing based on avian concerns.
  • The parties could not agree on whether Public Notice is required for Category #3 ASRs; see Section III.B, of the MOU for a discussion of this point.

    In addition, the MOU calls on the FCC to adopt and utilize a preferred lighting scheme for changes to existing towers that might minimize potential adverse consequences. The Conservation Groups rank FAA Lighting Styles in the following order, with the most preferred lighting system listed first and the least preferred light system listed last:

    FAA Style B (L-856)
    FAA Style D (L-865)
    FAA Style E (L864/L-865/L-810s)
    FAA Style C (L-856/L-865)
    FAA Style F (White Strobe Day/Red Beacon Night and L-810s)
    FAA Style A (L-864/L-810)

    (A complete description of each FAA Lighting Styles and the manner in which it is to be deployed is found at FAA, U.S. Dept. of Transportation, Advisory Circular: Obstruction Marking and Lighting, AC 70/7460-1K, (Feb. 1, 2007).)

    Thus, If the owner of an existing tower plans to change from one FAA Lighting scheme to another, the Lighting Preference Chart would be used to determine whether the change would require a Category #2 or Category #3 ASR to be filed:

  • A change of lighting system from a less preferred FAA Lighting Style to a more preferred FAA Lighting Style would require the filing of a Category #3 ASR, and
  • A change of lighting system from a more preferred FAA Lighting Style to a less preferred FAA Lighting Style would require the filing of a Category #2 ASR.

    A copy of the MOU is available here. NAB is optimistic that the Commission will endorse the agreement and avoid a significant percentage of broadcast towers ASRs from having to submit an Environmental Assessment at the time of application/public

  • Latest Top (5) News

    FirstNet's hunt for a replacement GM may enable a fresh start

    The surprise announcement that Bill D'Agostino, the First Responders Network Authority's general manager, has resigned, could provide a fresh start for the authority, which is still struggling to satisfy critics in the public-safety community.

    Sun, 20 Apr 2014 05:44:05 +0000

    Ericsson, NSN and NYU Wireless ramp up 5G efforts

    Ericsson has become the ninth major international technology firm to join NYU Wireless as an affiliate sponsor, giving added momentum to the research center's efforts one week before the start of its inaugural Brooklyn 5G Summit, which is being jointly organized with Nokia Solutions and Networks.

    Thu, 17 Apr 2014 06:41:55 +0000

    Google and Facebook conjuring up drone magic, but the public has concerns

    Google's acqusition of drone maker Titan Aerospace, which followed Facebook's newly announced initiative with drone maker Ascenta, reflects tech magicians' visions for new ways of enabling Internet connectivity. But John Q. Public is less than enthusiastic about unmanned aerial vehicles, perhaps because drones can also serve as flying broomsticks for the wicked witches of surveillance.

    Thu, 17 Apr 2014 01:17:18 +0000

    Time Warner announces massive Hotspot 2.0 deployment

    Time Warner Cable confirmed its rollout out of "TWCWiFi-Passpoint," a national Wi-Fi network that includes Hotspot 2.0 technology on most of its public access points as well as upgraded encryption.

    Wed, 16 Apr 2014 22:27:59 +0000

    Ranking the wireless industry's 10 highest-paid CEOs

    "Mirror, mirror, on the wall, who's the highest-paid CEO of them all?" In the wireless world, the answer to that question is Sprint CEO Dan Hesse.

    Wed, 16 Apr 2014 20:23:36 +0000
    FCC YouTube Feeds

    Latest Top (5) News

    Technology Transitions and Public Safety Workshop - April 17, 2014
    For more information, see
    Views: 0
    0 ratings
    Time: 07:07:49 More in Science & Technology

    Sat, 19 Apr 2014 05:45:13 +0000

    Consumer Advisory Committee Meeting - March 28, 2014
    For more information, see
    Views: 13
    0 ratings
    Time: 04:14:08 More in Science & Technology

    Fri, 04 Apr 2014 03:33:15 +0000

    Open Commission Meeting - March 31, 2014
    For more information, see
    Views: 17
    0 ratings
    Time: 02:37:51 More in Science & Technology

    Fri, 04 Apr 2014 00:03:25 +0000

    Rural Broadband Workshop - March 19, 2014
    The Rural Broadband Workshop focused on the importance of broadband in rural America and included presentations designed to elicit information to help develo...
    Views: 0
    0 ratings
    Time: 05:05:21 More in Science & Technology

    Wed, 26 Mar 2014 05:40:19 +0000

    CSRIC Meeting - 3/20/2014
    The Communications Security, Reliability and Interoperability Council (CSRIC) is a federal advisory committee that will provide recommendations to the Commis...
    Views: 12
    0 ratings
    Time: 02:40:53 More in Science & Technology

    Fri, 21 Mar 2014 21:48:43 +0000
    FCC News

    Latest Top (5) News

    2014 Quadrennial Regulatory Review - Review of the Commission's Broadcast Ownership Rules and Other Rules Adopted Pursuant to Section 202 of the Telecommunications Act of 1996
    FCC Adopted TV JSA Attribution Rules, Begins 2014 Media Ownership Quadrennial Review, And Proposed Benefits For Small Business Owners. Actions Will Help Protect Consumers and Preserve Local Broadcasting. by FNPRM

    Broadcast Actions

    Broadcast Applications

    Chapin Enterprises, LLC, Application for a Construction Permit for a Minor Change to a Licensed Facility, Applications for Minor Modification of a Construction Permit, Station KVSS(FM), Papillion, Nebraska
    Dismissed in part and denied in part the Application for Review filed by William B. Clay

    Notice of Request for Access to FCC Form 471 Item 21s and FRN-Level Data Regarding the Predominant Service Requested By E-rate Applicants
    PLEADING CYCLE ESTABLISHED; Opposition Date: 04/28/2014